I see strong 2nd quarter profits at Boeing,  just after hearing their strategy VP explain their heavy use of strategy models. Their industry model led them not to cut production after a 2009 collapse in orders, in spite of screams from analysts that they should do so to cut costs. Reminds me Airbus used a similar model way back in 96 (also in link above) to spot that a massive jump in orders was fluff, and to be cautious about adding capacity. (Back then, Airbus could only supply part of the market, so they couldn””t have captured Boeing””s 98-9 peak deliveries).

Message here – you can””t do strategy with 2×2 boxes, Vision statements and spreadsheets – you need rigorous and powerful models of your business and its environment. And this is not just for big boys and girls - my friend Warren Farr who runs RSC, a regional distributor of heating, ventilation and air-con equipment, built a strategy model of his market. This told him a market slow-down was not a normal cycle but a fundamental shift to an era of lower demand. Competitors kept expanding, believing growth would return – Warren held back and banked the cash. When competitors failed, he bought up cheap capacity and failed businesses, putting RSC into a strong position – much to the delight of employees who would otherwise have lost their jobs.

www.strategydynamics.com

Back in 1999 I got booed for saying the dot-com boom was mostly hot air, after which the NASDAQ dropped from 1000 to 200. The Economist now warns of a 2nd bubble,with private equity and big corporates falling over each other to throw cash at anything web-ish. Many of the new ventures will be great, but most will fail, due to poor understanding of whether business models are viable – which needs a sound system-model of the business.
As noted before, certified analysts are not required to understand anything about the link from strategy to performance, so we can be sure disasters will follow, as we see the NASDAQ drive up from 300 to 600 …
For a route to sound strategy and business models, see www.strategydynamics.com.

Fascinating Economist article on two recent studies of Germany’s outstanding long-run success. It’s down to their ‘Mittelstand’ mid-sized companies relentless pursuit of apparently boring but lucrative niches, and similar strategies by their larger, but little-known firms. More detail on their strategies in the article and references. Others tell me this is backed up by very strong involvement from bank-investors, rather than disinterested arms-length investors nagged by foolish analysts chasing every quarterly forecast. Not sexy, but rock-solid.

www.strategydynamics.com

Further to Analysts Getting it Wrong, a set of McKQ articles explain that just meeting investor expectations does nothing to the share price or, therefore, to total shareholder returns. Executives get on a relentless treadmill with every surprise performance requiring still another to boost TSR. It is troubling, then to see one quoted company Strategic Plan start with ‘Our aim is constantly to exceed shareholder expectations‘, which of course is impossible.

Kraft foods finally won control of Cadbury with a big £11.9 billion ($19.4b) offer. Warren Buffet, owner of 9% of Kraft, says it’s a bad deal – and he’s rarely wrong. Will Kraft do the usual and try to extract ‘synergies’ by slashing costs, or deliver real value by leveraging the combined resources to drive medium- to long-term growth in cash flows? … and will analysts allow them to do it right?

I have noted before that stock analysts need know little about how strategy affects firm performance, so an academic study on the impact of stock analysts on firms’ investment behaviour is intriguing. Continue reading »

I have been tough on the poor strategy seen over both of the last two boom-bust cycles, so good to see in Sensible Giants from the Economist that the largest listed firms have disproportionately little debt compared with both smaller listed peers and private firms. Continue reading »

I’ve gone on about this before, but it’s gone way, way worse since I last brought it up, so let’s not forget Continue reading »

© 2012 Talking about strategy Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha